22 May 2020
Posted in Banking
Digital challenger bank Bo’s failure underlines need to be independent from parent, says GlobalData
The Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS’s) digital challenger bank, Bo, has closed down after just five months. Incumbent banks aren’t predetermined to fail in building a challenger to take on Monzo, the UK-based online bank. To have a successful run, banks need to let them be free to innovate and create their own brands, says GlobalData, a leading data and analytics company.
Katherine Long, Retail Banking Analyst at GlobalData, comments: “Bo is the kind of bank that should never have been launched. It had no real purpose and purely existed because of NatWest’s realization that something had to be done. The result was a sterile, yellow interface that offered basic banking services and limited personal financial management tools to users.
“There was little excitement on launch and it was never really clear why consumers, particularly young people, shouldn’t just ignore Bo and instead go to Monzo.”
And the numbers mirror this feeling. After spending £100m (US$123m) – considerably more than Monzo – Bo managed to attract a measly 11,000 customers in just six months before it was disbanded. To put that into perspective, that’s just 1/20th of the number of people who downloaded Monzo in February 2020 alone.
However, this sequence of events is by no means inevitable. A perfect example of this is Up, the creation of a collaboration between tech company Ferocia and Bendigo and Adelaide Bank, an Australian regional community bank.
Up has been tremendously successful. It has amassed 185,000 customers with at least US$68m in deposits since its launch 18 months ago and continues to grow at up to 1,000 customers a day. Up has the highest-rated banking app in Australia, something many consumers are drawn to and a target that Bo probably never even dreamed of achieving.
Long concludes: “Independence from the mother company has been the key determinant of success for Up, allowing the bank to fully develop its own brand while being able to rely on the resources and expertise of its parent. For incumbents wishing to do the same as NatWest without ending up like Bo, Up’s example is a great one to follow.”